ASK & DISCUSS
INDEXThe value of The Blacklist
9 years, 2 months ago - David Hughes
Does anyone have any experience of listing a script on The Blacklist? I have paid for hosting and single evaluations on two of my 'active' (unsold) scripts, and have had tremendous feedback and quotable quotes. The scripts have been downloaded and read, and sometimes rated, by industry professionals, and I have been able to use the quotes in promoting the scripts. But does anything ever come of these kind of paid-for services (Slated, InkTip, etc.) other than the above – like, people actually optioning scripts? I'd be curious to know if any other SPs are hosting scripts and/or have received evaluations from The Blacklist.
Only members can post or respond to topics. LOGIN
Not a member of SP? JOIN or FIND OUT MORE
9 years, 2 months ago - Dan Selakovich
While I've never used any of these services, there have been many scripts optioned, purchased and produced from them. I'd stay away from inktip, simply because their bar for producers is pretty high, so the pool is smaller. Slated works differently. To be successful on Slated, you really need to have at least part of a package done. In other words, is a star attached? Or a great director with a track record? Slated uses a points system, so I think it necessary to have a lot of the leg work already done to get your ranking high enough. Slated has investors as part of their system, and they'll typically invest in many films on Slated to spread their risk. So it's more of a "matching service" between producers and money.
Response from 9 years, 2 months ago - Dan Selakovich SHOW
9 years, 2 months ago - David Hughes
Well I have some experience of that: we had enough elements for our Slated project – actor, actress, director, producer, screenwriters, sales company – to reach the required number of points to set the financing rolling... and when Slated agreed we had reached the relevant points total, they said "Ah, sorry, we aren't able to finance the project at this time" – so essentially we wasted months getting the package together under Slated's agreed terms, and they still said 'No.' Which of course makes me question their entire model (not to mention business practices, since they have essentially defrauded us). I wonder if we are alone in this experience, or whether anyone has actually had a film funded by Slated, rather than just listed on Slated and independently/coincidentally funded elsewhere.
Response from 9 years, 2 months ago - David Hughes SHOW
9 years, 2 months ago - David Hughes
Also, regarding InkTip, "the bar for producers" is actually pretty low, although tbf they do state when a producer doesn't have the requisite experience but has been allowed to post a project anyway. It's not like they're asking for proof of experience (much less proof of funds), it seems to me.
Response from 9 years, 2 months ago - David Hughes SHOW
9 years, 2 months ago - Dan Selakovich
@David Hughes I know a couple of producers with feature credits that couldn't get into Inktip to save their lives. And if I know 2 personally, I just expanded that out. Weird.
Sounds like Slated screwed you, but I wouldn't say that time was at all wasted. You have a package now. But I don't think it's too healthy to think that Slated, or anybody else, is going to green light a project. What's fucked about your experience, is that you reached their points minimum, which is quite high, and they didn't push it through to investors. That is really odd.
I think what I'm learning here, is that just about everyone has a horror story about each of these services. Like I said, I've never used any of them. While I don't know anyone that's sold through Blacklist, the people I know that used it (in its early incarnation) didn't have any bad things to say. Perhaps doing one round on each service is viable, since everyone hates each for different reasons.
Response from 9 years, 2 months ago - Dan Selakovich SHOW
9 years, 2 months ago - Gregory Fishwick
From what I can gather, Blacklist is very much geared towards separating you from your money. I've got a script on Inktip at the moment; I think it's worth every scriptwriter doing a stint on Inktip; the preferred newsletter is a good bonus and I've had one script viewing through a submission via that. But, as always, it all comes down to money and it's whether it's worth paying to keep it up there for just mainly logline views. When renewal time comes round, I probably won't renew, just to save myself some dollars but if money wasn't an issue I most likely would.
Response from 9 years, 2 months ago - Gregory Fishwick SHOW
9 years, 2 months ago - David Hughes
Do you use InkTip to follow preferred leads, or do you post your logline in the magazine?
Response from 9 years, 2 months ago - David Hughes SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer
@David Hughes I have spent a few year on inktip without tamgible results, yes lots of logline views, script downloads etc but no produced work. That's not the 'fault' of Inktip, my scripts were just not what they were looking for. About 20-30 films get made each year through Inktip, they tend to be low budget or movies of the week but they do get made. I also tried the Black List. No results. Had two reads and evaluations but they were fifty dollars each. For a page. So actually pretty expensive. At the end of the day I was paying twenty five dollars a month to be on a list, a list that got longer every month. I could buy some pretty good script development with that three hundred dollars. I won't be going back to the Black List and I'm off Inktip at present. I have no knowledge about Slated at all.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick
@David Hughes I've done both but the preferred newsletter, I think, is the most valuable aspect.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick
@Gregory Fishwick The preferred newsletter obviously being where the leads are.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - shirley day
I found Black list expensive. The valuations were okay, but investing regular money in a script that wasn't being looked at didn't really work for me. I think if you've got the money then it's probably worth a shot. Ink Tip, I go through phases of using and I have had some interest, but nothing optioned. I would agree with the comment that the bar can be pretty low on some producers, however there are some good ones on there too. I've had more interest through scripts on Shooting People, and one commision. It's difficult to know the best way to "float" your script. It's certainly doing you no favours sat on your hard drive. I've had one option through Script Boutique as well, and that is free. Haven't tried slated, but will take a look. I was wondering how much it actually cost to be a writer these days?
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - shirley day SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer
Shirley makes great points, for example through Shooting People I have found a paid writing gig for a very established director, had meeting on scripts, had options taken up and in fact one of those meetings eventually led to co-writing work on a film, that led to an original screenplay being produced, that led to an assignment to adapt a play - again produced, that led to the director and producer of my next film, also an original screenplay. So let's not not forget SP
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - David Hughes
@Peter Spencer Interesting. How did SP work for you, in the sense of "through Shooting People..."
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - David Hughes SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer
@David Hughes Well I pitched twice on SP which led to a flurry of meetings. One of the meetings led to an option that led to director attachment though the film finally did not get made. Another meeting led to a friendship and collaboration with a TV cameraman who went on to direct two low-budget features, one I co-wrote and one I wrote. The second of these films led to a paid gig to adapt an award-winning stage play - https://vimeo.com/130571374
On another occasion a director who made documentaries posted on SP for a writer to work on a thriller. It took a year or so of gentle emailing to get a meeting and by then the thriller was no longer on the table, BUT she was working on a historical bio-drama and I got the paid gig to write that. I've also met people at SP events that led to collaborations and it was through SP posts that I learned of the London Screenwriting Festival in 2010 - that led to some great friendships and contacts and also an offer at LSF 2011 from a production company that wanted to buy a pitch.
Over the years I have also been very proactive, going to events, making contacts and setting up pitches. The film I am working on now came about because I met a TV producer at an event in April 2015 (in fact it was the premiere of my film 'All The ordinary Angels'), pitched my bodyswap in a few sentences and she immediately said "I'll produce that." and here we are, setting up to apply for BFI First Feature funding deadline in September. But everything is about keeping the pressure on to come up with new material and keep writing, to not be afraid to meet people and be someone they want to work with.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Franz von Habsburg FBKS MSc
I've been on The Black List (and get 20% discount being a member of the WGGB) and Inktip. Just come off both: evaluations on the former were insulting, bearing in mind it's just been praised by Stephen Fry who wants to be in it (see what he writes at www.MargeryBooth.com) and the latter I felt a waste of money bearing in mind my film is a 100% European which is of absolutely no interest whatsoever to Americans, although Jerrol and team have always been most friendly and cooperative.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Franz von Habsburg FBKS MSc SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Ed Wiles
Interesting discussion. I put a low budget thriller script up on Blacklist briefly. I thought the notes were fair (though only got a 6) but the reader labelled it as high budget, which was ridiculous. I questioned this and got a pretty shitty response. I explained why it was incorrect and their response included the argument that if it had big names in it, it would be high budget. WTF? I never sent my response to that as it was obviously pointless. They will back their readers no matter what. But they pay their readers very little so they are not going to be great. I heard a guy had placed in several competitions and then got a 1 on Blacklist...
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Ed Wiles SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - steve Savitz
Thanks for reminding me to remove my script from Blacklist. I never paid for reads and as a result I get zero results. i've gotten 1 script view since april - whatever a view means. i've gone to the brooklyn area monthly meetup for Blacklist as well and no one I've met has ever had anything positive to say. We should all remove our scripts today and donate our next premium to an environmental charity. maybe our karma will improve.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - steve Savitz SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick
Yeh, I've heard the common response from Blacklist when you query something is "pay for another review"
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick
Regarding what Shirley and Peter said, I'm interested as to what you would say is the best way to utilize SP; how did your successful experiences come about? Was it due to job postings, script pitches, going to an event etc.?
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer
Well I pitched twice on SP which led to a flurry of meetings. One of the meetings led to an option that led to director attachment though the film finally did not get made. Another meeting led to a friendship and collaboration with a TV cameraman who went on to direct two low-budget features, one I co-wrote and one I wrote. The second of these films led to a paid gig to adapt an award-winning stage play - vimeo.com/130571374
On another occasion a director who made documentaries posted on SP for a writer to work on a thriller. It took a year or so of gentle emailing to get a meeting and by then the thriller was no longer on the table, BUT she was working on a historical bio-drama and I got the paid gig to write that. I've also met people at SP events that led to collaborations and it was through SP posts that I learned of the London Screenwriting Festival in 2010 - that led to some great friendships and contacts and also an offer at LSF 2011 from a production company that wanted to buy a pitch.
Over the years I have also been very proactive, going to events, making contacts and setting up pitches. The film I am working on now came about because I met a TV producer at an event in April 2015 (in fact it was the premiere of my film 'All The ordinary Angels'), pitched my bodyswap in a few sentences and she immediately said "I'll produce that." and here we are, setting up to apply for BFI First Feature funding deadline in September. But everything is about keeping the pressure on to come up with new material and keep writing, to not be afraid to meet people and be someone they want to work with.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer SHOW
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Nick Brown
Sounds like some bad experiences but I listed a script on there recently that got optioned after three weeks. I'm prepared to accept that was very lucky but for $25 a month, I'd say it's well worth it. As we all know, the key difficulty for writers is connecting with directors and producers and it does at least offer that as a genuine possibility.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Nick Brown SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Ed Wiles
Well done on the option. Can I ask what the budget range/genre was so we have an idea of what might work?
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Ed Wiles SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Nick Brown
@Ed Wiles
Thriller. Budget probably 5m plus. But I think it's very much down to a director/producer finding what they're looking for.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Nick Brown SHOW
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Nick Brown SHOW
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Peter Spencer SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - shirley day
Congratulations to Nick on the option. Reference Gregorys question as to how links were made through shooting people. I think one was through the scriptwriters bulletin, and the others were through the script pitch. Black List certainly appears to be for an American market, but then I think maybe psychological thriller, action, and horror, probably are more easily transferable. You would certainly pay travel costs to get to a meeting to pitch your script, so perhaps the price is not so high, but maybe it's worth targeting easily transferable genres.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - shirley day SHOW
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Gregory Fishwick SHOW
9 years, 1 month ago - Ronnie Mackintosh
Hi David, I pitched a feature on Inktip and it's been optioned by a prod co in the States. I also pitched one to Amazon Studios (http.studios.amazon.com) and they've selected it for inclusion on their Notable Projects page. Good luck with everything. Ronnie www.ronniemackintosh.co.uk.
Response from 9 years, 1 month ago - Ronnie Mackintosh SHOW